Stresa (and Hemingway) in Monochrome

We started our three-week visit to Italy in 2009 with a four-day stay in Milan and after seeing just about everything we wanted to see in two days we then on day three took the train to Stresa, a resort town on the shores of Lake Maggiori about 50 miles north of Milan.  Readers of Ernest Hemingway’s World War I novel A Farewell to Arms may recall that some of the major events in the novel took place in Stresa. They say that Stresa is a beautiful place when it isn’t raining. Unfortunately for us, it rained most of the day.

Window shopping in Stresa.

Click any photo to see a larger version of that photo.

It took us an hour and a half to reach Stresa.

Typical architecture in central Stresa. The building on the left is the Hotel Moderno.

Our walk from the train station to the lake brought us to Piazza Cadorna, named after Generale Luigi Cadorna, chief of staff of the Italian army during most of World War I. Cadorna was relieved of his command after suffering a major defeat at the Battle of Caporetto. He spent the rest of the war representing Italy at the Allied Supreme War Council in Versailles. In 1924 Mussolini appointed him Marshall of Italy. Cadorna died in 1928.

Piazza Cadorna on a rainy day.

In May 1915 Cadorna launched an offensive against the Austro-Hungarian Empire along the Isonzo River in northeast Italy. Two years and five months and eleven battles later the two armies were still pretty much in the same place and the Italian army began to settle down and wait out the winter. But Karl I, the emperor of Austria had other ideas. He wrote to his German allies for help and they responded on October 26, 1917 with a poison gas attack and an infiltration of crack German stormtroopers. It was the 12th Battle of the Isonzo, also known as the Battle of Caporetto, and a disaster for Cadorna and Italy. 40,000 Italian soldiers died, 280,000 laid down their arms and surrendered, and 350,000 deserted. Cadorna issued orders for summary executions of officers. He is even accused of bringing back the old Roman tradition of decimation — executing every tenth soldier — whenever a legion was humiliated in battle.

Another view of Piazza Cadorna.

Hemingway begins A Farewell to Arms with his protagonist Frederic Henry, an American serving as an officer in the Italian Army in charge of a fleet of ambulances in Gorizia, a town on the border with present-day Slovenia about 50 km northwest of Trieste. Frederic is severely wounded in a mortar attack and is sent to the American Hospital in Milan for surgery and recuperation. Book Two in Hemingway’s tale is a love story between Frederic and his British nurse Catherine Barclay. In Book Three a recuperated Henry returns to the Front and is sent to Caporetto about 55 km north of Gorizia just in time for the German offensive. The Italian army is routed and soon in full retreat and the carabinieri are called upon to execute officers they find among the retreating soldiers. Frederic escapes execution and becomes a deserter. He stows away on a train to Milan and on his arrival discovers that Catherine has been transferred to a hospital in Stresa. At the end of Book Three he grabs another train to Stresa.

We walked on from the piazza and soon came across this little church about a block from Corso Italia along the lake.

Exterior of Chiesa di San Michele.
Interior of Chiesa di San Michele.
I think this bell tower is of another church.

A few more blocks took us to the shores of Lago Maggiori.

Corso Umberto I, Stresa’s main shoreline road. That’s the Grand Hotel des Iles Borromees in the background on the far left. Hemingway stayed there. So did Frederic Henry, the main character in A Farewell to Arms.

In Book Four of A Farewell to Arms Frederic finds his way to the Grand Hotel des Iles Borromees where he and Catherine reunite. He befriends Emilio, one of the hotel’s bartenders, who informs him one evening that the police plan to come in the morning to arrest him. Emilio lends him his boat and stocks the boat with food and drink from the hotel. Frederic and Catherine row all night the 35 miles up Lake Maggiori to the Swiss border. Hemingway concludes his story in Book Five with an account of Frederic and Catherine’s life together in Switzerland during the winter of 1917-18.

As close as we got to the Grand Hotel des Iles Borromees.

In A Farewell to Arms nothing good happens when it rains. And the rain got to us that day in Stresa. We turned around here and walked back to the train station. I was soaked and spent most of the next day in bed.

Lake Maggiori and one of the Borromean islands.

After Milan we visited Venice for four days. In my next post we will look at some photos from that trip. And maybe we’ll discuss another Hemingway novel.

About crowcanyonjournal

I am a family man with interests in family history, photography, history and travel.
This entry was posted in History, Italy, Literature, Travel and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Stresa (and Hemingway) in Monochrome

  1. Peter Klopp says:

    You must have many happy memories of your trip to Italy over 10 years ago. It is one way to deal with the pandemic when we delve into our pleasant experiences of the past.

    • Thanks, Peter. After Italy we decided to travel every year and we did so for ten years. Then came Covid and we hardly ever leave our house anymore. So I play with favorite old photos. And re-read favorite old novels.

      • Peter Klopp says:

        As you know we live in a relatively remote and isolated area of BC where Covid has not shown its ugly face yet. We have been blessed with exceptionally fine weather for this time of the year and enjoy our daily walks into nature. Best wishes to you and your family! Peter

  2. disperser says:

    Interesting seeing names of places near where I grew up (Gorizia, Caporetto, etc.). I was born in Jesenice (Slovenia) but grew up near Udine (the small town of Zugliano). South of Udine there’s Mortegliano and Lavariano where my uncle — mons. Giovanni Nicolich — served as priest until he passed away in 2011.

    When I was younger, I often heard my mother speak of Caporetto, but wasn’t aware it was part of the territory Italy lost to then Yugoslavia. When she spoke the name, it always sounded as if it was part of Italy (which it was before the war).

    The monochrome treatment went well with the rainy photos.

    • Thanks for the comment, Disperser. In my research for this post I learned that Caporetto is the Italian name for the town Slovenes call Kobarid and the Germans called Karfreit. In Hemingway’s novel Frederic Henry was heading for Udine on foot during the Italian army retreat but he soon realized that German stormtroopers on bicycles were going to get there before him. So he detoured and eventually found the train to Milan.

      Speaking of names, did you find the the hotel bartender’s moniker also interesting?

    • disperser says:

      It’s always strange and jarring coming across my name because it happens so seldom.

      . . . although, I was familiar with Salgari very early on in my life. Even so, not that often that I hear or read it when not directed at me.

  3. kzmcb says:

    Your shots of piazza cadorna are beautiful. They’d make good jigsaws!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.